Did you know that the concept of home elevators dates back to ancient Rome, where they used simple hoists powered by human, animal, or water power?
Fast forward to today, and home lift options have evolved significantly, offering homeowners a wide array of choices to suit our current needs and preferences. Therefore, choosing the best home lift can be a daunting task. Each option brings its own set of advantages and considerations, ranging from ride experience and design to space requirements and cost implications.
In this blog post, we'll delve into the differences between the two most common home lifts currently on the market, traction lifts and platform lifts, providing clarity on what each type entails. By examining these factors closely, we aim to guide you towards making an informed decision that aligns with your specific needs and preferences. Whether you prioritise a smooth ride, sleek design, efficient use of space, or cost-effectiveness, understanding the nuances of these elevator types will set you on the path to selecting the ideal solution for your home.
Traction Lifts Explained
A traction lift operates using a system of ropes and counterweights. This type of lift is commonly found in both residential and commercial buildings due to its smooth ride experience and efficient use of space.
A traction lift has cables, a pulley, and a counterweight. The cables attach to the top of the elevator car, go over a pulley, and connect to the counterweight. This counterweight balances the car's weight, making it easier to move up and down, and typically weighs as much as a half-full car.
Furthermore, a traction machine, usually at the top of the elevator shaft, moves the lift. A brake system ensures the elevator stops at the right floor. A set of guide rails provides stability and a smooth ride as the lift travels up and down the shaft.
Traction lifts offer several advantages, including a smoother ride. The counterweight system helps to reduce the amount of energy required to move the elevator car, enhancing energy efficiency.
These features make traction lifts versatile and applicable in various settings, from residential homes to high-rise commercial buildings. They are particularly beneficial in situations where a smooth ride and efficient use of space are important considerations.
Platform Lifts Explained
Platform lifts operate differently from traction lifts and can be broadly categorised into two types, screw-driven and hydraulic.
A screw-driven platform lift works by using a screw and nut system. When the screw rotates using an electric motor, the nut moves the platform up or down. This lift is known for being reliable, smooth, and needing little upkeep. It's often quieter and uses less energy, so it's good for both indoor and outdoor use.
On the other hand, hydraulic platform lifts work differently. They use a pump and piston system. The pump pushes fluid into a cylinder, which moves the piston and lifts the platform. To descend, the fluid flows back into a reservoir, allowing the platform to lower slowly. These lifts can carry heavier loads. But, they might need more upkeep than screw-driven platform lifts and can be louder because of the hydraulic pump.
Best Efficiency: Traction Lift
When it comes to ride experience and efficiency, traction lifts have distinct advantages over platform lifts, mainly due to their greater travel speeds and automations.
Traction lifts are designed to travel faster and incorporate more automation. For instance, the lift doors open and close automatically at the desired stop, making them an excellent choice for those prioritising a smooth and efficient ride.
Furthermore, the system of ropes, counterweights, and a traction machine ensures the lift moves quickly and stops precisely, contributing to a seamless ride experience.
That being said, installing a traction lift comes with more considerations.
A traction lift necessitates a larger machine room, taller overhead space, a deeper pit, and a wider shaft.
These requirements mean that installing a traction lift often involves significant structural modifications, making it more costly. Also, the installation process tends to be longer, which can be a drawback for homeowners looking for a quick solution.
Most Customisable: Traction Lift
Traction lifts provide a wealth of customisation options for discerning homeowners who want to seamlessly integrate their lifts into their home's interior design. For instance, BELIFT's HES-6800 traction lift offers over 10 unique styles that can be further personalised.
Homeowners can choose from a diverse palette of colours and accessories, allowing the lift to complement the overall aesthetics of their home seamlessly. The customisation options extend beyond just colours and accessories. Homeowners can select from a range of materials for the walls, such as stainless steel, laminate, timber, aluminium, or glass, each available in various textures and finishes. Ceilings can also be altered with options like glass, laminate, or metal, complemented by lighting features to create a unique ambiance inside the lift.
For those interested in exploring the full potential of home lift design, our previous blog post, “Home Lift Customisation Guide: Selecting Suitable Materials and Finishes”, provides a comprehensive guide on how to select the perfect materials and finishes for your home lift. This guide delves into key considerations such as desired design inspirations, maintenance ease, budget, and safety, helping you achieve a personalised lift that complements your living space.
Space Optimisation: Platform Lift
A platform lift is the clear choice for homeowners who need a lift that requires minimal space.
Unlike traction lifts, which necessitate extensive structural modifications such as digging a pit or punching through the roof, platform lifts offer a much simpler installation process. This simplicity translates to a faster, easier, and more affordable installation.
Although platform lifts travel at slower speeds compared to traction lifts, this is generally sufficient for the height of a typical landed home. The installation process for a platform lift in Singapore is straightforward and cost-effective, with prices starting from $40,000.
The procedure begins with an initial site visit to assess the homeowner's needs and property. Following this, a detailed proposal and scope of work are provided. Once confirmed, the necessary parts, tools, and equipment are gathered for the lift installation, which typically takes between 6 to 12 weeks, with an additional 2 weeks for the actual installation. After extensive testing and receiving approval from the Building and Construction Authority (BCA), the lift is ready for use.
For those interested in a more detailed breakdown of the space optimisation benefits of platform lifts, we encourage you to read our previous blog post titled “Maximising Space: Compact Home Lift Solutions for Landed Homes”.
Cost Effectiveness: Platform Lift
Platform lifts are generally cheaper than traction lifts due to several key factors. One significant cost-saving aspect is the lack of enclosed walls on platform lifts, which reduces the amount of material and construction required. This open design minimises the complexity of building the lift shaft, resulting in a lower overall cost.
Another reason for the lower price point of platform lifts is the simplicity of their installation process. Unlike traction lifts, which require extensive structural modifications such as digging a pit or creating a machine room, platform lifts can be installed with minimal disruption to the existing structure of the home.
However, the cost savings of platform lifts come with certain trade-offs.
For instance, platform lifts typically have manual door operation and a 'hold to run' requirement, meaning the user must continuously hold a button for the lift to move. These features differ from the automated doors and one-touch operation that are standard in most traction lifts and other elevators we interact with daily.
While these conventions might be less convenient, they do not detract from the practicality of platform lifts, especially for homeowners who prioritise space optimisation and ease of installation.
Unlike other elevator companies that offer homeowners an arbitrary “best” option for home lifts, at BELIFT, we recognise the complexity and nuances of each project.
We understand that every home and homeowner has unique needs, which is why we provide multiple best options based on different considerations such as ride experience, customisation options, space constraints, and costs. Whether you are looking for the smooth, high-speed ride of a traction lift or the space-efficient, easy-to-install nature of a platform lift, BELIFT has a solution tailored to your specific requirements.
If you feel overwhelmed by the choices or simply need an expert to validate your decision, don't hesitate to contact us. Our team is here to guide you through the process and ensure you select the perfect lift for your home.
Comments